Text size :

Marco Follini: “In democracy, the adversary is a value”

ADNKRONOS

November 15, 2026

Rome, Nov 15. (Adnkronos) – “Aldo Cazzullo’s broadcast dedicated to the ‘very special’ day of May 9, 1978, brought back all the memories, fears, emotions, and ambiguities of those days, never too far from the Republic’s memory. But there is a dark, controversial point that resurfaces every time and that concerns not only the protagonists of that era but, to some extent, reaches us, our current political reality, however different it may be.

That point concerns the relationship between the Christian Democracy (DC) and the Italian Communist Party (PCI), between Moro and Berlinguer. It is summarized in the formula of the ‘historic compromise’. Overlooking the fact that this slogan, evoked by the communist secretary the day after the Chilean coup, was the banner waving in Botteghe Oscure. And yet, it was quite different from what the Christian Democratic and Morotean counterpart had in mind.

To summarize the meaning of that difference in a few, sparse words, one could say this: Berlinguer envisioned a strategic collaboration that would last over time and lead to a non-precarious and non-provisional formula. For him, it was about establishing a shared government for a sufficiently long, intense, and discontinuous period of history compared to what had been seen in action until then. And Moro, on the other hand, envisioned a much shorter transition, carefully preserving the entire Christian Democratic “army” and not frightening the more conservative part of his electorate. A transition during which Christian Democrats and Communists, historical adversaries, would collaborate to emerge from the emergency, only to then return to the country, as soon as possible, the possibility of choosing between one and the other. Without either bloc feeling threatened by the other’s affirmation.

Berlinguer’s goal, in short, was the construction of a new historical bloc, linking communists and Christian Democrats (possibly not all of them) to a shared destiny. Moro’s goal, on the other hand, to use his own words, was a new April 18th. That is, a challenge for the leadership of the country between two naturally alternative forces capable of not transforming their antagonism into a no-holds-barred struggle. Something similar to what happened in other Western countries, where alternation was not poisoned by the fumes of mutual delegitimization.

Therefore, no offense is done to the memory of either of them if it is recalled that their perspectives would soon be quite divergent. And no honor is paid to the dialogue that took place between them if it is framed within what would later be called “consociationalism”.

In the long run, it can be said that Moro and Berlinguer would hardly have governed together – except for a few moments, just long enough to emerge from the emergency. Because their histories were different, and their perspectives could not have resembled each other much. Something that I imagine was clear between the two of them. And that is, such as not to impede the collaboration that was needed in those months. But also not to push that collaboration beyond the Pillars of Hercules of those political and strategic differences to which both were attached.

In the following years, after Moro’s death and the end of national solidarity, a certain nostalgia for that lost collaboration lingered in some circles. And with it, also the fantasy that communists and Christian Democrats might have even grown closer. What was lost, however, was an even more fundamental value. Namely, the possibility of a dialogue between adversaries who intended to remain adversaries and not become allies.

Beyond Moro and Berlinguer, the crucial point – which concerns us even more today – is that in a democracy, the adversary itself is a value. It is a value as an adversary, not as a future ally. It is a value in the name of differences, not similarities. Finally, it is a value because democratic dialectics, the confrontation between competing parties and leaders, the dialogue that maintains distinctive characteristics and does not demand complicity or assimilation—all these things are vital for a democracy to function fully.

According to Moro, the DC would by no means have been the long-standing government ally of Berlinguer’s PCI in the medium term. It would have been its loyal and constructive antagonist. But the value of democracy lies precisely in trying not to erase differences. Taking care to prevent those differences from digging an abyss”. (by Marco Follini)

Jiji Press

Related

Page TOP