Rome, Nov. 18. (Adnkronos) – The legal “battle” undertaken by the former mayor of Rome Ignazio Marino ends with a new victory for Alessandro Onorato. The Rome Court of Appeal rejected the appeal filed by Marino against the judgment of the Rome civil court of October 2023, also condemning him to pay 7,000 euros in legal fees. At the center of the matter is the request for 50,000 euros in compensation made by the former mayor to Alessandro Onorato, today a councilor in the Gualtieri Capitoline junta but at the time sitting on the opposition benches, for statements made during a television broadcast dating back to October 2015 about trips abroad and the use of the city’s credit card. In that case, Onorato, among other things, had stated that “Marino was caught declaring false information: he used the credit card for non-common and non-institutional purposes.” The former opposition councilor then wondered why the mayor, “dubbed a Martian,” was allowed “improper use.” “I – Onorato said – personally caught him red-handed, that is, while he had told the Romans a lie about the trip to Philadelphia and New York, saying it was free for Romans, but instead it cost us a good 28,000 euros, for a purpose that was not of municipal and public interest.” Marino considered those statements defamatory, but both for the Court and for the Court of Appeal, they are statements attributable to political criticism.
“In the present case, the expressions used during the broadcast do not constitute and do not aspire, in the opinion of this Court, to be a verbatim reconstruction of facts concerning the actions of the then mayor of Rome, but – the judges of the First Civil Section of the Rome Court of Appeal emphasize in the judgment – they collectively integrate a criticism of the political conduct of the Capitoline Junta during the period in which Marino held that office.” For the judges, “the purpose pursued was not to proceed with a personal invective directed at Marino, but to address a criticism, albeit harsh, of the municipal political management as a whole and, consequently, of the person appointed to preside over it.” Therefore, “the attributions made in the television interview by Onorato and complained about by the appellant with the technique of isolating individual contents, thus carrying out an atomistic contestation, are therefore to be considered in light of the overall context of the debate, globally verifying their function. Having already excluded that the intervention can integrate the content of a review of historical facts, which would imply a more stringent adherence to reality, it appears – the judgment reads – an expression of a general criticism of the political line and actions” of the former mayor.
The expressions used by Onorato, therefore, “do not appear to exceed the limits of continence, appearing to be endowed with the necessary formal correctness and abstract functionality to the purpose of criticism pursued.” In light of all these considerations, the Appeal judges rejected the former mayor’s appeal, considering Onorato’s statements to fall within the exercise of political criticism.