Text size :

Valditara against the Laterza history book: “It must be withdrawn”. The reply: “No to censorship”

ADNKRONOS

November 10, 2026

Rome, Nov 10. (Adnkronos) – There is controversy over the history book ‘Trame del tempo 3’, published by Laterza and adopted in several high schools, for some passages dedicated to the government led by Giorgia Meloni. The textbook describes the executive as linked to a “declaredly fascist base” and defines the measures adopted on immigration as “liberticidal”. These words provoked the reaction of the Minister of Education and Merit, Giuseppe Valditara, who demands its withdrawal, also appealing to the scientific reputation of the publishing house.

“A text that, from a scientific point of view, is completely inadequate and risks being functional to the indoctrination of students. Frankly, representing this government as a government that deports immigrants by blacklisting them, a fascist government or whatever – says Valditara – I think it doesn’t do anyone any good,” the minister emphasizes.

“It is not acceptable for a minister or others to decide what should or should not be written in a text. It is not a question of merit, but of principle. For defamatory texts, there are courts,” Alessandro Laterza, head of the school division of the eponymous publishing house, replies to Adnkronos. “What I wonder – says Laterza – is why this story is resurfacing now. It’s an old story; at the end of June 2025, the minister asked the Italian Publishers Association, to which we refer, to intervene on this text because it was not welcome. The Aie replied that it was not its competence to exercise forms of control or censorship, and we, in turn, clarified that we were not available for suggested interventions on the text because freedom of thought, expression, and teaching still exists. No one ever said that this text would be withdrawn.”

As for the role of the publisher, Laterza specifies, “we are always co-responsible with the author. But our style is to respect authors and not intervene on content unless we identify a defamatory profile. And we – he concludes – do not habitually publish defamatory texts.”

Paola Frassinetti, Undersecretary for Education and Merit, also intervened on the matter, hoping for the withdrawal of the volume. “The school textbook ‘Trama del Tempo 3’ published by Laterza is an example of how history can be falsified with the aim of ideologizing young people. It would be desirable for the publisher to withdraw this text, which contains historical falsehoods, going so far as to accuse FdI of ‘implementing declaredly liberticidal measures’. Adopting biased books in schools does not help boys and girls grow with a critical spirit and generates historical falsehoods that contribute to their ideologization.”

The stance of Federico Mollicone, president of the Culture and Education Commission of the Chamber and deputy of Fratelli d’Italia, is also harsh, defining the passage in the textbook dedicated to the executive as “unacceptably serious”. “Delegitimizing historical reconstructions, lies about the executive’s actions, and infamous accusations of ‘deportation’. While respecting freedom of expression, last year we had already raised – together with Il Giornale and also with an intervention by Minister Valditara – these critical issues. The textbook, however, continues to be on sale and adopted in many Italian schools.” The FdI deputy argues that Giorgia Meloni deserves to be remembered in history books for her institutional role: “It is true, Giorgia Meloni deserves to be included in history textbooks: as the first woman to hold the office of Prime Minister and for representing the longest-lasting government in the history of the Italian Republic. The rest are insinuations and mystifying opinions that cannot belong to this type of educational publication.”

The Fratelli d’Italia deputy Grazia Di Maggio, a member of the Culture Commission, also calls for the withdrawal of the volume. “We had long realized that schools, with many of their textbooks, were a stronghold of the left. That they would go so far as to falsify history to discredit the Meloni government is truly too much. There is a limit even to lies and provocations, and this history text exceeds it.” Di Maggio also disputes the impact that such content could have on students’ education: “The ideology that pervades it, in young developing minds, leads students to wrong conclusions and prevents them from exercising a correct duty of criticism and in-depth analysis because it stems from a wrong premise, namely that the Meloni government is fascist and promotes ‘liberticidal laws’. I believe this text should be immediately withdrawn from all schools.”

Cristina Costarelli, president of the National Association of School Principals of Lazio, also intervenes in the controversy, expressing perplexity about the contents of the textbook. “I have no information that this text has been adopted by schools in Lazio, but if this is the content, I find it inadequate and inappropriate, especially in a school context. I don’t know how it could have come to this; I hope that few schools have adopted it and I hope it will be withdrawn from circulation,” she declares to Adnkronos.”

Finally, Alessandro Amorese, group leader of Fratelli d’Italia in the Culture and Education Commission of the Chamber, harshly criticizes the contents of the volume, focusing in particular on a passage on page 666. “What is reported in the history book Trame del tempo 3, published by Laterza, aimed at high schools, is truly dismaying. Reaching up to the present day, the history textbook on page 666, with a devilry typical of the left, describes the Meloni government as the heir of the Mussolini regime, with a ‘declaredly fascist base’, and a promoter of ‘declaredly liberticidal measures’, such as ‘the war on migrants’ through ‘deportation plans’. These are delirious and false statements: it is horrifying that books of this kind are adopted in the temple of culture and critical thought, as schools should be.”

Jiji Press

Related

Page TOP