Text size :

Saman murder, Cassation: “It was not an act of impulse but premeditated, she wanted a different life”

ADNKRONOS

November 6, 2026

Rome, 06 Nov. – (Adnkronos) – “Saman’s murder is not to be considered an act of impulse, or in any case extemporaneous, but a premeditated decision to sanction the dishonor brought by the girl, who intended to live according to social canons different from those of her origin”. This is what the judges of the First Criminal Section of the Cassation Court write in the reasons for the sentence that made the convictions for the murder of Saman Abbas, the 18-year-old Pakistani girl killed on the night between April 30 and May 1, 2021, in Novellara di Reggio Emilia, definitive.

In July, the supreme judges rejected the appeals of the accused family members, confirming the four life sentences handed down on April 18 last year by the Bologna Court of Appeal to the girl’s parents, Shabbar Abbas and Nazia Shaheen, and to her cousins Noman Ul Haq and Ijaz Ikram, accused of murder and concealment of a corpse, and the 22 years of imprisonment decided for her uncle, Danish Hasnain, who had been sentenced to 14 years in the first instance, with the aggravating circumstances of premeditation and heinous motives recognized, deemed equivalent to the generic mitigating circumstances already granted for the cooperation provided in finding the body.

The sentence had accepted what was requested by the General Prosecutor’s Office of the Cassation, with Attorney General Marco Dall’Olio, who had emphasized in the indictment that they were facing “not a crime of impulse but a premeditated action. That Saman could not decide for herself is clear, manifest, the reconstruction of the facts is unequivocal. Saman, even if an adult, could not decide her own life, she could not have a life of her own. A chilling story, a collective and premeditated act.” Saman was killed in the driveway in front of her house and buried in a hole a short distance from the family home in Novellara. The 18-year-old’s boyfriend had alerted the police. The young woman’s body was found a year and a half later, on November 18, 2022, after her uncle, who had fled abroad and was captured in Paris, indicated to investigators the place where she had been buried. “The District Court impeccably highlights a convergence of elements preceding, concomitant with, and subsequent to the crime – write the supreme judges – the existence of a clear motive (violent opposition to the daughter’s life choices, conflicting with their perceived model of existence and life, and her decision to definitively leave the family home) and the concretization of the motive itself, at the moment when the accused (Shabbar Abbas ed.), on the evening of April 30, 2021, viewed the girl’s chats – reads a passage from the 100 pages of reasons – the preparatory telephone contacts between the accused and his brother Hasnain, as such clearly identifiable, being absolutely unusual in terms of frequency, duration, and time within the ordinary family routine, and highly predictive of the final concertation.”

And again, “the targeted accompaniment of the victim towards the place that would immediately after become the scene, as is undeniable, of the deadly ambush; the luminous signal immediately preceding this accompaniment; the delivery of the girl to her mother, who takes over her final guidance; the inert but conscious waiting of the man, who adopts a tormented attitude upon returning (even without intervening, confirming full, even psychological, adherence); the recovery of an object likely identifiable as the backpack (a concurring, but not decisive, circumstantial element); the departure the next day for abroad, entirely without plausible justification and without notifying his son, still a minor; the phrases uttered in conversation with his son after Saman’s disappearance, understood by the trial judges as clear admissions of responsibility for her death,” the sentence reads.

The intention to kill “had arisen and had been maintained over time, but its execution was subordinated to Saman’s decision to leave, this time definitively, the family unit and escape its control. When this decision manifested itself irreversibly in the father’s eyes, through the unauthorized intrusion into the girl’s private conversations, the plan was implemented, and the challenged sentence provides a conclusive and convincing illustration of this,” the Cassation judges further write. The “family clan” had already decided Saman’s death “previously, albeit for the very real possibility that the girl would not give up her alternative life project. The invitations to stay, addressed by the mother to Saman shortly before the latter was killed, had nothing genuinely protective about them. It is at this point that the mother, as plastically carved by the challenged sentence, with logical reasoning, adhering to the procedural data and thus immune from any censure, accompanies her daughter to her death – the supreme judges emphasize – leading her, unaware, towards the path where the other relatives were waiting for her for the material execution.” (by Assunta Cassiano)

Jiji Press

Related

Page TOP