Rome, Nov 6. (Adnkronos) – The Tribunal of Ministers should have explained the reasons why it did not consider Dr. Giusi Bartolozzi, at the time Head of Cabinet of the Minister of Justice, to be liable as an accomplice in the crimes attributed to the latter in relation to the arrest and subsequent release of Osama Almasri, which took place between January 19 and 21, 2025. The Public Prosecutor’s Office of Rome, for its part, should have communicated the College’s assessment to the Chamber. However, a violation of the Chamber’s prerogatives was excluded in relation to the failure to request authorization to proceed against Dr. Bartolozzi for the allegedly false statements she made to the Tribunal of Ministers during a hearing held on March 31, 2025. This is, in summary, what the Constitutional Court established with sentence number 190, filed today, with which it partially upheld a conflict of attribution between state powers proposed by the Chamber against the Tribunal of Ministers and the Public Prosecutor’s Office of Rome.
The Court noted that, following the investigations carried out by the Tribunal against the Minister, the Public Prosecutor’s Office had expressly invited the Tribunal to qualify Dr. Bartolozzi’s conduct as complicity in the crimes attributed to Minister Nordio, or, alternatively, to hypothesize the crime of false statements during the investigations against her. By virtue of the principle of loyal cooperation between the powers of the State, in the face of this request, the Tribunal should have explained the reasons why it did not consider configuring, for Dr. Bartolozzi, a possible responsibility for complicity in the crimes attributed to the Minister. If it had configured such complicity, in fact, the Tribunal should have asked the Chamber for authorization to proceed also against Dr. Bartolozzi herself, in addition to the Minister. For its part, the Public Prosecutor’s Office should have communicated the Tribunal’s assessments to the Chamber, in order to enable it to eventually promote a conflict of attribution against the judicial authority, if it had considered that the Tribunal’s decision had violated its constitutional prerogatives.
The Court, however, excluded that there was an obligation for the Tribunal and the Public Prosecutor’s Office to request authorization to proceed against Dr. Bartolozzi for the different crime of false statements. The Chamber’s argument was not shared, according to which the obligation to request authorization to proceed established by Article 96 of the Constitution for crimes attributed to a minister in the exercise of his functions would also extend to crimes committed by a third party and simply connected to ministerial ones, such as – hypothetically – false statements made with the aim of concealing a minister’s responsibility.
In this regard, the Court emphasized that the specificity of the discipline of ministerial crimes, with the connected guarantee of authorization to proceed to protect government action, excludes an extensive interpretation of the authorization discipline itself. Any institutional confidentiality requirements regarding circumstances learned from persons interrogated by the Tribunal who do not hold ministerial functions can be protected, where the legal conditions exist, through the instrument of opposing state secrecy.