(Adnkronos) – The panic that for some hours paralyzed six thousand schools in Italy, the alerts that shook the main airports in France, the United Kingdom, and the Italian peninsula itself, and the growing tensions crossing community borders are not isolated incidents, but pieces of a much more complex mosaic. Providing an overview of this phase of strong instability in an interview with Adnkronos is Heli Tiirmaa-Klaar, a technology expert at the German Marshall Fund, the Washington D.C. think tank specializing in strengthening cooperation on security and geopolitical challenges between Europe and the USA. According to the Estonian analyst, Europe is in the era of “shadow warfare”. “First of all, authorities must establish who is behind these threats. If it were a state actor, it would be truly concerning. It would be an important component of this shadow war. But if it were a criminal group, or perhaps just a prank, then it would be a completely different story,” says Tiirmaa-Klaar.
In recent weeks, the recurrence of false bomb threats and disruptive actions has severely tested citizens’ nerves and the emergency response system. Incidents like the thousands of Italian schools thrown into disarray by spam emails, later revealed to originate from a Taiwanese account, demonstrate how extremely easy it is to generate chaos by exploiting digital channels. Nevertheless, the demarcation line between a youthful prank, an organized crime action, and a social engineering operation orchestrated by a foreign state remains subtle but fundamental. “Remember the cyberattacks against French supermarkets and others, which were found to originate from Iran? As you can see, in these cases, attributing responsibility is very important. We cannot make assumptions before knowing who was responsible. It’s difficult to say how we should respond, but certainly, Europeans must become more resilient,” reiterates the expert, emphasizing how the political and diplomatic response crucially depends on the certainty of evidence. While Europe looks with apprehension at its vulnerabilities, the transatlantic perspective offers a different interpretation. The chaos recorded at American airports this Friday led to fears of the worst, immediately suggesting a large-scale cyberattack. In reality, it was a technical glitch, related to a technological update for the transition from copper cables to fiber optics.At the same time, according to the German Marshall Fund analyst, on the pure cybersecurity front, the US position appears solid: “Generally, the United States is quite advanced in terms of cyber resilience: organizations, especially in the transportation and airport sectors, use the most advanced technologies, and many American IT companies are very robust. I am not particularly concerned about cyberattacks on critical infrastructure in the United States, because cybersecurity experts know what to do and how to build resilience.” However, the expert warns against any excessive optimism: perfection does not exist. There always remains room for action for a highly skilled attacker capable of exploiting complex vulnerabilities to cause systemic disruptions.
In the Old Continent, the regulatory framework has made giant strides, particularly thanks to the adoption of the NIS (Network and Information Security) directive, now transposed by all member countries. This legislative shield ensures that critical infrastructures have adequate basic protection standards. “This does not mean that security is one hundred percent. There always remains the possibility that a very experienced attacker could penetrate defenses and, with sophisticated and advanced attack methods, cause chaos.”The true Achilles’ heel, in fact, does not lie in large control centers, but in peripheral, seemingly marginal devices connected to the network. “What we saw with supermarket refrigerators in Europe could be an example of one of those weak links that have been attacked,” observes Tiirmaa-Klaar. “Refrigerators are not part of critical infrastructure, but they are internet-connected and insecure devices. This is one of the weak links we have. The problem in Europe is that we should not have weak links of this type: we should also protect all these vulnerable points.”
The challenge for the future lies not only in passing new laws – explains Tiirmaa-Klaar – but in ensuring that individual states rigorously apply existing regulations, extending security requirements to the private sector as well. Faced with evacuated schools, blocked airports, and alarmist headlines, the public’s emotional reaction often oscillates between bewilderment and fear. The experts’ advice in the face of this wave of hybrid threats is clear: “The best advice is to remain calm and carry on, because the threats have remained just that: nothing happened, right? It is still very, very concerning that they were made.” Resilience, ultimately, is not just a matter of firewalls, encryption, and emergency protocols for critical infrastructure, but also involves the collective maturity of a society capable of not succumbing to panic, while simultaneously demanding rapid and transparent responses from institutions. “We already have regulations. Now it is up to individual European countries to ensure they implement them and impose standards and requirements on the private sector as well, so that all organizations address cybersecurity,” concludes Tiirmaa-Klaar. (by Iacopo Luzi)