Livorno, Nov 10. – (Adnkronos) – “No new evidence on the causes of the disaster”. The Livorno Public Prosecutor’s Office has initiated legal procedures for notifying the injured parties of the request for dismissal of the proceedings against unknown persons related to the Moby Prince ferry disaster, which occurred in the roadstead of the port of Livorno on April 10, 1991, in which 140 people died. This was announced in a statement by prosecutor Maurizio Agnello. The proceedings had been registered with the Public Prosecutor’s Office for the crime under article 422 of the penal code (intentional massacre) following the submission of the final report by the second Senate Inquiry Commission on the causes of the Moby Prince disaster, presented on December 11, 2017, which had highlighted several critical issues, errors, and omissions in the past reconstruction of the facts.
In parallel, the Florence Anti-Mafia District Directorate had also registered a separate proceeding to investigate any mafia or terrorist origins of the disaster. The investigations had a negative outcome and led to the request for dismissal on December 3, 2024, which was accepted by the Florence Preliminary Investigations Judge with a decree on February 27, 2025.
“The new and in-depth investigations,” explains prosecutor Agnello, were conducted by the Public Prosecutor’s Office with the assistance of the Gico of the Florence Guardia di Finanza and included the questioning of numerous witnesses, the acquisition of documents from public bodies and private companies, the assignment of multiple technical-scientific consultancy tasks, and telephone interception activities. A review of all the findings from the multiple proceedings and trials conducted over 35 years concerning the collision between the Moby Prince and the oil tanker Agip Abruzzo was also carried out.
“All investigative hypotheses that could be classified as a cause or contributing cause of the disaster were carefully and, at times, re-examined: the weather and sea conditions at the time of the event, the position of the Agip Abruzzo oil tanker at the time of the collision, the effectiveness of the safety devices on board the ferry, the confused coordination of rescue efforts, the possible alteration of the Moby Prince’s route due to a third vessel,” explains the Livorno prosecutor. “However, these investigations have not revealed concrete elements of responsibility, negligent or intentional, either against individuals previously investigated or against third parties. No new hypotheses susceptible to further investigation into the causes of the tragedy have emerged either.”
In 2019, the Livorno Public Prosecutor’s Office had also initiated proceedings against unknown persons for the crime under article 377 of the penal code (obstruction of justice): investigators had hypothesized that some witnesses might have been induced to lie during their questioning, but the telephone and environmental interceptions activated for this purpose did not confirm this hypothesis.
“The time elapsed since the disaster, which occurred 35 years ago, has made investigations into an event of extraordinary gravity particularly complex: such a long interval can diminish even the most vivid memories of direct witnesses still alive and makes it extremely unlikely that a technical consultant can answer the questions posed by the judicial authority with certainty – explains prosecutor Maurizio Agnello – To these difficulties is added the legal constraint of ne bis in idem for positions already subject to previous jurisdictional assessments.” And, with reference “to the detrimental effects of the passage of time,” the Public Prosecutor’s Office notes that “the only crime not covered by prescription would have been that provided for by art. 422 c.p. (intentional massacre): all other conceivable crimes (negligent massacre, or multiple negligent homicide, or even shipwreck) are now to be considered irremediably extinguished.”
“It would therefore be necessary to demonstrate, for the existence of the crime under art. 422 c.p., that someone intentionally acted to cause the death of 140 people – or at least accepted the risk of doing so, where so-called ‘dolus eventualis’ (conditional intent) is applicable – outside the context of subversive terrorism or mafia criminality, in relation to which the Florence DDA has already investigated and requested and obtained the dismissal of that proceeding,” writes the prosecutor.
The Public Prosecutor’s Office “deemed it necessary to carry out further investigations, also out of respect for the victims and their relatives, who, in an associated form, have constantly requested that the causes of the disaster be ascertained. This commitment was undertaken with full awareness of not being able to investigate merely suggestive hypotheses.” Following the investigations, the Public Prosecutor’s Office also “carefully evaluated the impact on its determinations of the procedural innovations introduced in 2022 by the so-called Cartabia reform. In particular, it considered art. 335 c.p.p., relating to the prerequisites and methods for registering suspects in the register of crime reports, and arts. 408 and 425 c.p.p., with reference to the criterion of reasonable expectation of conviction for the purpose of exercising criminal action.” Once the procedures for notifying the injured parties of the request for dismissal are completed, the file will be transmitted to the preliminary investigations judge of the Court of Livorno for competent decisions.