Text size :

Roberto Burioni, warning from Privacy Guarantor: “Personal data of the signatories of the complaint against him made public on his social media”

ADNKRONOS

November 7, 2026

Rome, Nov 7. (Adnkronos) – According to Adnkronos, the Privacy Guarantor has issued a warning against immunologist Roberto Burioni for non-compliance with the principles of lawfulness, fairness, purpose, and data minimization of the Privacy Code that govern data processing for journalistic purposes. Personal data such as general information and excerpts from identity cards related to some of the signatories of the disciplinary complaint filed against him with the provincial order of Surgeons and Dentists of Pesaro-Urbino had been published on some of Professor Burioni’s social profiles. Subsequently, the personal data of the signatories, originally reported in the posts published on social platforms, were removed. With provision 755 of October 7, 2026, the Privacy Guarantor Authority reiterated the principle of the essentiality of information regarding facts of public interest as a parameter for data processing carried out in the exercise of journalistic activity and, more generally, freedom of expression.

“In particular – the provision reads – the disclosure of the identity of some of the signatories of the complaint does not appear to be justified in terms of the essentiality of the information, necessity, and proportionality with respect to the possible purpose of stimulating a critical debate on the complaint of which he was the recipient, but rather as an illustrative indication of the signatories to whom he personally addressed his criticisms, given their significant number.” According to Professor Burioni’s defense, “there would be no reason to omit the names of individuals who, by criticizing his work with complaints and disciplinary actions, would intend to undermine his scientific credibility and, therefore, would force him to defend himself publicly and by all means, including his own scientific dissemination channels.”

The Privacy Guarantor Authority reiterated that “the provision falls within those carried out in the exercise of freedom of expression and that therefore Articles 136-139 of the Code relating to data processing in the context of journalistic activity and other forms of expression of thought, including the right to criticize, certainly apply to it.”

The Guarantor then emphasized that the personal data protection regulations provide specific guarantees and precautions in the case of processing carried out within the scope of freedom of expression, confirming their lawfulness, even where they take place without the consent of the data subjects, provided that they occur in compliance with the rights, fundamental freedoms, and dignity of the persons to whom the processed data refer. “This deviates from having published the names and part of the identification documents of some signatories of the disciplinary complaint sent to the relevant order, as it was a disproportionate reaction in terms of the aforementioned justification cause under Article 21 of the Constitution regarding the right to criticize and, more generally, the expression of thought,” it is highlighted.

As for the alleged attempt to misuse the disciplinary instrument to personally discredit the virologist, according to the Guarantor Authority, “this does not justify the conduct of disseminating and commenting on social media the data of certain individuals who, in availing themselves of a legally recognized protection instrument, do not hold a role or qualification that justifies their identification in the context under examination. The dissemination of names, surnames, and excerpts of identification documents of the promoters of the complaint, accompanied by personal reactions and comments directed at the mentioned individuals, does not appear suitable to provide useful informative contribution on the facts subject to the disciplinary complaint, proving to be more pertinent for this purpose, from the recipient’s point of view, to focus on the alleged groundlessness of the arguments advanced by the generality of the exponents rather than dwelling on individuals, moreover mentioned by the data controller only for illustrative purposes, as he highlighted.” Finally, the Privacy Guarantor points out “that having deleted the posts is not a conduct entirely suitable to remove their harmful effects, since the identifying data of the three signatories of the complaint have nevertheless remained available to the data controller’s large social following.”

Jiji Press

Related

Page TOP