Rome, Nov 17 – (Adnkronos) – “No mere imprudence or inexperience in calculating danger and means of salvation was found in the action” of Mario Roggero who “with a voluntary and conscious choice, channeled his action into a deliberate aggression not justified by the necessity of defense”. This was written by the judges of the First Criminal Section of the Cassation in the 34 pages of the reasons for the sentence with which, last July 15, the 14-year and 9-month conviction for the jeweler from Grinzane Cavour was finalized. In April 2021, following a robbery in his shop, he killed two robbers and wounded a third.
Further conduct, the supreme judges write, “was unequivocally considered indicative of Mario Roggero’s intention to take justice into his own hands. Moreover – it is underlined in the sentence – it was the defendant himself, in interviews released after the fact, recalled in the reasons for the appealed sentence, who stated that the initiative taken represented the only way to stop the robbers and bring them to justice”. The appealed sentence “has correctly excluded the existence of legitimate self-defense, real or putative, based on a prudent assessment of the concrete situation in which the defendant found himself, deemed such as not to legitimize the emergence of the conviction of having to defend himself or others from an unjust aggression and to necessitate harmful action: Roggero – it is reported in the sentence – had chased the robbers outside the jewelry store, firing gunshots at a time when the robbery was already over and the criminals were intent on fleeing; the homicidal conduct was carried out at a time when the danger to life and personal safety and that of relatives had already ceased, as the defendant himself had clearly perceived.”
The possibility that “the robbers, intent on fleeing with the loot, would change their mind and return to the jewelry store to endanger the safety of the people inside is entrusted by the appellant to merely hypothetical representations, devoid – the supreme judges highlight – of any factual connection and disproved in their plausibility by the already occurred apprehension of the stolen goods and the proximity to the car intended for escape”. The trial judges, it is reported in the sentence, remarked how “the expert analysis of Roggero’s behavior during the robbery had not shown an impairment of the perception of reality, but an impulsive mode of reaction to events, already recorded during the dispute in 2005 with the family of his daughter’s boyfriend.”
For the Cassation judges, therefore, “the homicidal intent was deduced, with an assessment firmly anchored to the investigative findings and free from manifest illogicality or contradiction, from the rapid succession of multiple gunshots, at man height and from a short distance, in the direction of the victims”. The acceptance of the lethal event in terms of foresight, for the judges, “prevents the requested reclassification of the charges into cases of negligent homicide or involuntary manslaughter, to which this subjective connotation is extraneous.”