Members of the Senate Impeachment Court on Tuesday, November 10 grilled Vice President Sara Duterte’s second witness over his inability to explain details why a property officially located in Barangay San Isidro, Kaputian, was listed under Barangay Matanos in the Vice President’s Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net worth (SALN).
On Day 41 of the impeachment trial, Senator-judge Erwin Tulfo questioned Island Garden City of Samal Assessor Engr. John Kenneth Enumerables over his failure to provide concrete details on the location of the property listed in her SALN, saying that a city assessor should be familiar with the areas within his jurisdiction.
The defense team presented Enumerables to establish that the property, covered by Transfer Certificate of Title (TCT) No. 142-2019013134 had been declared in Duterte’s SALN.
The said property is a 751-square meter lot in the upscale Kembali Coast residential development registered under her husband, Atty. Manases “Mans” Carpio’s name. The said property has an assessed value of P346,960 and a market value of P4,956,600.
Enumerables, however, acknowledged that the property’s official location differed from the one listed in Duterte’s SALN.
“How did you become an assessor if you don’t know the location?” Tulfo asked. “What if you are confronted with so many papers and still you don’t know the place you are assessing?” the senator-judge further asked.
Enumerables later on conceded he was unfamiliar with the said location listed in her SALN. He also admitted he was unfamiliar with Matanos and whether it is indeed a sitio of Barangay San Isidro.
When Tulfo reiterated his question to Enumerables, Impeachment Court Presiding Officer Francis “Chiz” Escudero clarified that Enumerables had consistently identified San Isidro as the property’s official location.
“It was the Vice President who indicated in her SALN the name of the barangay (Matanos),” Escudero pointed out.But later during the course of the trial, Enumerables confirmed that no Barangay Matanos exists in Samal.
“There is no Barangay Matanos in IGACOS,” Enumerables told the impeachment court.
The said disputed property is part of the remaining impeachment charge that pertains to Duterte’s alleged unexplained wealth under Article 2.
Escudero then challenged Duterte’s defense team to prove that a disputed property in Samal Island was actually declared in her SALN, following a similar dispute over Duterte’s alleged property in Davao City during Monday’s hearing.
The presiding officer was referring to the testimony of Davao City Assessor Engr. Jaime Adalin, whom the defense presented as their first witness when they sought to establish that a property in Matina Crossing, Davao City registered under Duterte’s husband had been declared in her SALN.
The House prosecution had identified the property as among those supposedly undisclosed by the vice president in her SALN, but the defense insisted it was already included in her SALN under a different location description.
Pointing to Enumerables’ testimony, Escudero advised defense lawyer Lindon Miguel Bacquel to clearly establish the actual identity of another disputed property rather than merely suggest a possible match.
“Kindly help us out to remove it from the realm of possibilities to the actual realm of actuality that this is really it,” Escudero told the defense panel.
“Kindly help us see that, counsel, through this witness (Enumerables), if indeed that is what this witness will be testifying on,” he reiterated.
House prosecution counsel Benjamin Tolosa Jr. maintained, however, that there were glaring discrepancies between the property identified in the land title and the property listed in Duterte’s SALN.
“There’s no way that this witness could prove that they are the same properties. All that he could testify to is, again, at most, they are in the same barangay,” Tolosa reiterated.
Enumerables’ admission came amid intense scrutiny over glaring discrepancies between Carpio’s land title documents and Duterte’s SALN entries.
For one, the Deed of Absolute Sale which Enumerables presented pursuant to subpoena was executed on March 15, 2018, whereas Duterte’s SALN repeatedly reported that she acquired the property in 2013.
When Escudero observed that Duterte’s filings originally listed the mode of acquisition as “installment” in 2015 before shifting to “sale” five years later, Tolosa pointed out that neither the title nor the deed contained any installment terms or reference to a prior contract to sell.
Senator-judge Joel Villanueva, for his part, questioned Enumerable on the five-year discrepancy: “If this property was acquired in 2013, do you have any document evidence that would prove it was acquired in 2013 and that it was the same property in the 2018 deed of absolute sale?”
To which Enumerable, again conceded that he could not confirm this as he currently does not have access to additional documents pertaining to the property.
‘Evasive’
Prior to this, Escudero warned the succeeding witnesses of the defense panel that they risk being cited in contempt, or face a possible perjury case if they would lie, or be evasive in answering questions posed by senator-judges.
This after Senator-Judge Vicente Sotto III made such a reminder when he asked Escudero to “refresh his memory on this matter so that the witnesses and the prosecution and the defense be reminded as well.”
Sen. Panfilo “Ping” Lacson supported Sotto’s point citing Senate Resolution No. 39 of the RUles of Procedure on Impeachment Trials that established the impeachment court’s contempt powers.
“This was adopted by the Senate Impeachment Court in March of 2011. And it expressly grants the impeachment court the power to cite for contempt of the court anybody for that matter,” Lacson said.
“They may be subject to contempt by the court, Your Honor. And in addition to that, may be subjected to cases of perjury should one be filed against him before the proper prosecutor’s office and or courts of law. Because the statements given by any witness is under oath and is therefore, covered by our laws on perjury as well,” Escudero said.
Escudero then turned to Enumerables: “Engineer, you heard what the senator-judges said against the actuations of the witness yesterday. I hope you can avoid the same thing when you testify today.”
Escudero added that succeeding witnesses before the impeachment court should not behave like Adalin.



