Text size :

Impeachment court admits most of prosecution evidence vs VP Duterte; rejects general defense objection

MANILA BULLETIN

November 6, 2026

The Senate Impeachment Court has overruled the defense’s general objections to the prosecution’s documentary evidence in the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte, allowing most of the evidence to be admitted in the remaining Article II charge, subject to specific exclusions and limitations.

In a 22-page order signed by Presiding Officer Francis “Chiz” Escudero on Nov. 5, Thursday, the court expressly rejected the defense’s continuing objection to the evidence on the grounds that the documents were not attached to the original impeachment complaints or articles and were obtained through subpoenas issued during the trial.
“The Court overrules the continuing objection,” the order stated.
The defense had argued that the prosecution’s evidence resulted from an impermissible “fishing expedition.” The court, however, ruled that describing the use of subpoenas in this manner does not automatically justify excluding the documents.
It said each exhibit must still meet the requirements of relevance and competence, remain within the scope of the subpoenas and applicable court rulings, and comply with confidentiality and authentication requirements.
The court also admitted records dating from 2007 to 2021, before Duterte assumed office as vice president, but limited their use to establishing a financial baseline against which her assets, liabilities, net worth, financial resources, transactions and business interests from 2022 to 2025 may be evaluated.
It said the earlier records cannot be used to charge or prove separate offenses allegedly committed before her current term, establish liability for conduct outside Article II, or revive any withdrawn impeachment article. They also cannot be used merely to suggest a habit or propensity to violate the law.
Article II is the sole remaining charge against Duterte after the court confirmed the withdrawal of Articles I and IV with prejudice and Article III without prejudice on Oct. 13.
The court admitted Duterte’s Statements of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALNs) from 2007 to 2025, as well as a Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA) certification and the marriage certificate of Duterte and her husband, Manases Carpio.
It also admitted various Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) records, including corporate registration documents, general information sheets, and audited financial statements; Philippine Government Electronic Procurement System records; Philippine National Police Firearms and Explosives Office records; and Land Registration Authority documents.
The admitted evidence also includes Anti-Money Laundering Council reports, bank records, insurance and investment documents, Bureau of Internal Revenue records, and a financial forensic report prepared by lawyer Alexander Cabrera.
The court said the AMLC records may be considered to establish the existence, filing or issuance of identified reports and the transaction flows reflected in them, insofar as these are relevant to Article II. It maintained that disclosure through lawful court processes is distinct from unauthorized disclosure and directed that protected information be handled securely.
Bank documents were admitted for relevant account details and recorded transactions, while insurance and investment records may be considered for policy, investment, ownership, payment, and account particulars. Questions concerning attribution, valuation, disclosure requirements, and the evidentiary weight of these records remain for the senator-judges to determine.
The court also admitted BIR records concerning reported income, assets, and business interests. However, Duterte’s income tax returns for 2017, 2018, 2019, and 2021 cannot be used to establish an independent liability or violation outside the scope of Article II. Letters of Authority issued by the BIR were admitted only to establish their issuance and the scope of the authorized tax examination.
The court excluded corporate records of JTC Group of Companies Philippines Inc. and Pikimong Pikimong Philippines Corporation, including entries, summaries, schedules, and computations derived from those records in other exhibits. It clarified that independently admissible portions of documents concerning other entities would remain in the record.
It also excluded evidence relating to Commission on Audit findings and notices of disallowance involving confidential fund disbursements by the Office of the Vice President and the Department of Education in 2022 and 2023.
The court said those documents were offered in connection with Article I, which had been withdrawn with prejudice, and could not be re-offered or raised collaterally in relation to Article II.
The remainder of Cabrera’s forensic report was admitted as his analysis of independently admitted evidence. However, the court said the report’s assumptions, methods, totals and inferences would remain subject to its independent evaluation.
The court emphasized that admitting evidence does not establish the truth or accuracy of its contents, nor does it mean the tribunal has adopted the prosecution’s legal conclusions.
“Admission does not, ipso facto, establish the truth or accuracy of any such evidence”, the order stated, adding that the weight and sufficiency of every admitted exhibit would be determined by the senator-judges during final deliberations.
With the resolution of the prosecution’s formal offer of documentary evidence, the prosecution is deemed to have formally rested its case-in-chief on Article II.
Duterte is scheduled to begin presenting her evidence-in-chief on Nov. 9, with her defense limited to the remaining Article II charge.
Jiji Press

Related

Page TOP