Text size :

Impeachment court: Petition vs voting threshold ruling ‘fatally premature’

MANILA BULLETIN

November 5, 2026

The Senate Impeachment Court on Thursday, November 5 defended its ruling on the voting threshold for convicting an impeached official, insisting that it did not amend the Constitution and that the Supreme Court (SC) should dismiss the legal challenge filed by Senators Robin Padilla and Christopher “Bong” Go.

In a statement, impeachment court spokesperson Atty. Regie Tongol said the tribunal, through the Office of the Solicitor General (OSG), filed its comment before the Supreme Court on Nov. 3, seeking the outright dismissal of the petition and the denial of any injunctive relief.
Tongol said the Senate’s authority under Article XI, Section 3(6) of the Constitution to try and decide impeachment cases includes the power to resolve questions concerning the computation of the two-thirds voting requirement when some senators are legally or physically unable to participate in the proceedings.
He maintained that the September 23 ruling did not alter the constitutional requirement for conviction but ensured that only senator-judges who actually heard the evidence would be counted in determining the vote.
The Senate Impeachment Court also rejected allegations of grave abuse of discretion, pointing out that it heard arguments from both the prosecution and defense and consulted four retired Supreme Court justices who served as amici curiae with the parties’ agreement.
Tongol said the ruling was also reached through an open and recorded vote.
“There can be no grave abuse of discretion when a constitutional tribunal hears both the Prosecution and the Respondent, consults four retired Supreme Court jurists appointed as amici curiae with the parties’ agreement, and resolves the issue by an open, recorded vote,” Tongol said.
He further argued that the petition was premature because the Sept. 23 ruling, which was issued pro hac vice, did not automatically exclude any senator from participating in the proceedings.
“Above all, the petition is fatally premature and warrants no temporary restraining order or status quo ante order because the September 23 pro hac vice ruling excludes no one by itself, requests by detained Senators to participate remain pending, and the voting denominator may never shrink at all,” he said.
Requests by detained senators to participate in the impeachment trial also remain pending, he said, adding that the number of senators counted in determining the voting threshold may not necessarily be reduced.
The Senate impeachment court said it would not allow the pending legal challenge to delay the proceedings, citing the constitutional directive that impeachment trials must proceed without delay.
The presentation of the defense’s evidence-in-chief on Article II of the impeachment complaint against Vice President Sara Duterte will continue as scheduled on Monday, November 9, Tongol said.
Jiji Press

Related

Page TOP