The opinions of some senator-judges and lawyers clashed in the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte on Wednesday, November 11 when the matter between evidentiary weight and admission against interest became the center of discussion with the defense panel’s fourth witness.
On Day 42 of the trial, Senator-judge Panfilo “Ping” Lacson asked this question to Atty. Suzette Balucanag-Punay, in-house counsel for GenCorp. Industries Inc. and Metro City Chow Foods Corp. which are two entities linked to Duterte.
The defense panel presented Balucanag-Punay as its fourth witness to counter allegations made by the House prosecution panel that the Vice President had undeclared business dealings.
But during the course of the hearing, the witness confirmed that Duterte remained as director of Metro City Chow and continued to draw cash disbursements from the operation of a Jollibee branch in Davao City under GenCorp.
She also told the impeachment court about the “loose investment” the Vice President in GenCorp. from which she is received P2.14-million in returns of capital from 2022 to 2025.
“This is getting to be interesting, but also confusing. From a layman to a lawyer, Atty. Suzette, between an admission against interest—notarized—and official public documents like the GIS (General Information Sheet), which has more admissibility and probative weight?” Lacson asked.
Punay responded that she believes records coming from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) have more probative weight.
However, Lacson countered this citing Rule 130 of the Rules of Court regarding the rules of admissibility.
“What I know is that there is more probative weight or admissibility weight when it is an admission against interest,” Lacson said.
“I actually know someone who ended up in jail just for making an admission on television. In this case, the SALN (Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth) is involved,” he pointed out.
Impeachment court presiding officer Francis “Chiz” Escudero said, however, the matter is subject to the appreciation of the senator-judges.
Defense counsel Atty. Justin Gular, for his part, said that an admission against interest is an exception to the hearsay rule.
“We have to be clear, Your Honor. Admission against interest is not a rule on probative value. It is an exception to the hearsay rule,” Gular said.
“In other words, comparing pieces of evidence and statements and the probative weight thereof, with all due respect, is done by the respective court and this case, the senator-judges,” he explained.
But private prosecutor Atty. Lorna Kapunan asserted that an admission is the “highest” in the hierarchy of evidence, citing the Rules of Court, that said the act, declaration, or omission of a party as to a relevant fact may be given in evidence against him or her.
At this, Escudero acknowledged that both counsels have valid points.
“Nobody is wrong. Atty. Justin is correct that admission against interest is indeed an exception to the hearsay rule,” Escudero said.
“Atty. Lorna is, likewise, correct that admission per se has been characterized in fact as the ‘queen of evidence,’ will carry more probative weight especially if it comes from the accused,” the presiding officer stressed.



