The Senate impeachment court has ruled that the sub judice principle will continue to apply to all articles of impeachment against Vice President Sara Duterte, including those withdrawn by the prosecution, and reiterated its directive barring public commentary on matters covered by the pending trial.
In a Nov. 5 order signed by Presiding Officer Francis “Chiz” Escudero, the court resolved an appeal by Senator Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan following the withdrawal of three of the four impeachment articles against Duterte.
The court ruled that the sub judice principle under Rule XVIII of the Rules of Procedure on Impeachment Trials shall ” apply with equal force to all articles of impeachment, whether withdrawn or pending adjudication.”
It also upheld and reiterated the presiding officer’s Aug. 26 ruling on the application of Rule XVIII, enjoining all persons covered by the directive from making, issuing, or promoting public statements or commentary concerning the merits of the pending trial or any matter covered by the articles of impeachment.
“Any violation of this directive shall be dealt with in accordance with the strict penalty system under the guidelines set forth in the aforementioned ruling,” the order stated.
The ruling came after the prosecution withdrew Articles I, III, and IV of the impeachment complaint on Oct. 13, leaving Article II as the sole remaining charge against Duterte.
Following the withdrawals, the presiding officer ruled that the sub judice principle under Rule XVIII no longer applied to the withdrawn articles.
Duterte’s counsel objected to abandoning the rule. During the same proceedings, Pangilinan said he was willing to seek reconsideration of the ruling when the trial resumed on Nov. 9 and that Rule XVIII should remain in force in the meantime.
With Pangilinan’s permission, the presiding officer said the court could consider the appeal filed once Duterte confirmed her position. The court then authorized Escudero to rule on the appeal during the recess.
On Nov. 4, the court received Duterte’s manifestation, filed through counsel, stating that she was not waiving the protection of Rule XVIII and that the sub judice rule should be maintained and enforced to preserve the integrity of the proceedings and respect her constitutional rights.
After considering the manifestation and Pangilinan’s appeal, the court issued its Nov. 5 resolution extending the rule’s application to all four articles, regardless of their withdrawal or pending adjudication.



