HOME > AFP-JIJI PRESS NEWS JOURNAL > Article
French Senate speaker 'astounded' by Macron 'ignorance' on Israel
The speaker of the French Senate -- the country's second most senior figure under the constitution -- said Thursday he was astounded by remarks attributed to Emmanuel Macron on Israel and accused the president of showing his ignorance of history.
Macron was quoted as saying in a cabinet meeting Tuesday that Israel must not forget it owed its existence to a United Nations resolution after its troops fired on UN peacekeepers in Lebanon.
The comment sparked a furious reaction from Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, adding to growing tensions between France and Israel, and also troubled Jewish community figures within France.
It first of all shows an ignorance of the history of the birth of the State of Israel, Gerard Larcher, the right-wing speaker of the upper house, told Europe 1 radio.
Questioning the existence of Israel touches on fundamental questions for me, he said.
I was astounded that these remarks could be made, he added. The creation of Israel did not come as a notarial act merely validated by the UN, he argued.
Larcher would take over the presidency if centrist Macron was incapacitated or suddenly resigned. He is a senior figure in the right-wing Republicans (LR) party to which Prime Minister Michel Barnier also belongs.
Mr Netanyahu must not forget that his country was created by a decision of the UN, Macron told the weekly French cabinet meeting, referring to the resolution adopted in November 1947 by the United Nations General Assembly on the plan to partition Palestine into a Jewish state and an Arab state.
Therefore this is not the time to disregard the decisions of the UN, he added, as concern grows over Israeli fire on UNIFIL peacekeepers in southern Lebanon.
His comments from the closed door meeting at the Elysee Palace were quoted by two participants who spoke to AFP and asked not to be named.
In a blistering attack that is highly unusual from an establishment figure in France, Larcher questioned if Macron had taken account of the 1917 British Balfour Declaration, which supported the creation of a Jewish homeland, and even the Holocaust and its consequences.
Netanyahu has hit back at Macron's comments, saying the country's founding was achieved by the 1948 Arab-Israeli war, not a UN ruling.
He also said that among those who fought for Israel in 1948 were French Jews who had been sent to death camps after being rounded up by the collaborationist Vichy regime, which governed a large part of France during the Nazi occupation in World War II.
In an interview with France's Le Figaro daily published Thursday, Netanyahu accused Macron of a distressing distortion of history and disrespect.
(2024/10/18 17:08)
Click Here for Japanese TranslationAFP-JIJI PRESS NEWS JOURNAL
- 10/18 18:34 Canada marine protection plan aims to serve as global model
- 10/18 18:27 Musk stumps for Trump in key US swing state
- 10/18 18:20 Mbappe to keep any explanations for Swedish justice, 'if necessary' - lawyer
- 10/18 17:08 French Senate speaker 'astounded' by Macron 'ignorance' on Israel
- 10/18 17:03 One Direction members 'devastated' by Liam Payne's death
- 10/18 17:00 Trump says Zelensky 'should never have let' Ukraine war start
- 10/17 17:04 'Nowhere is safe'-- Lebanon Christian villiage reels from Israel strike
- 10/17 17:01 Bondi beach 'closed' as Sydney shores hit by 'tar balls'
- 10/17 16:59 UN report says 1.1 billion people in acute poverty
- 10/17 16:57 Three US presidents join Kennedy clan at Ethel Kennedy funeral
- 10/17 16:55 South Korea's Hwang Ui-jo faces four years in jail for sex video
- 10/17 16:54 Israeli minister criticises Macron over France defence show ban
- 10/16 17:22 Portrait by humanoid robot to sell at auction in art world first
- 10/16 17:16 'Mysterious black balls' close Sydney beaches
- 10/16 16:32 North Korea claims more than a million people joined army this week
- 10/16 16:31 Harris mocks Trump after rally turns into bizarre dance-a-thon
- 10/16 16:30 Kylian Mbappe 'shocked' to see name linked to Swedish rape investigation
- 10/16 16:29 Russia working to undermine Moldova vote-- US
- 10/15 19:26 Biden's back (not) and Kamala sips a brewsky
- 10/15 19:24 K-pop star tells South Korea lawmakers of workplace bullying
- 10/15 17:35 Mbappe 'investigated for rape' in Sweden-- report
- 10/15 17:28 US, Philippines launch war games a day after China's Taiwan drills
- 10/15 17:24 Trump says could support using US military against Americans
- 10/15 17:23 'I still plan to compete and play next season,' says Djokovic
- 10/11 17:33 Harry's Bar in Paris drinks to US straw-poll centenary
- 10/11 17:27 MLB Twins up for sale after 40 years
- 10/11 15:26 Erdogan says Gaza 'shame of humanity', calls for permanent ceasfire
- 10/11 15:16 A very stiff breeze-- BBC says sorry for 20,000 kph wind forecast
- 10/11 15:15 Federer lauds retiring Nadal's 'incredible achievements'
- 10/11 15:13 UN probe accuses Israel of seeking to 'destroy' Gaza healthcare
- 10/10 18:12 As Great Salt Lake dries, Utah Republicans pardon Trump climate skepticism
- 10/10 18:09 Wildlife populations plunge 73% since 1970-- WWF
- 10/10 18:07 McIlroy and DeChambeau set for PGA-LIV 'Showdown' in Vegas
- 10/10 18:05 Biden slams Trump for 'onslaught of lies' over hurricanes
- 10/10 16:55 Activists target Picasso work to protest Israel arms sales
- 10/10 16:53 Greek international Baldock, 31, found dead in pool-- state agency
- 10/09 21:59 Gilded canopy restored at Vatican basilica
- 10/09 21:53 Pyongyang to 'permanently' shut border with South Korea
- 10/09 21:45 Nepali becomes youngest to climb world's 8,000m peaks
- 10/09 17:03 Syria says seven civilians killed in Israel Damascus strike
- 10/09 17:00 Osama bin Laden's son Omar banned from returning to France