CA voids Leila de Lima acquittal, sends drug case back to RTC
The Court of Appeals (CA) has voided a Muntinlupa court’s decision acquitting presumptive congresswoman Leila de Lima in one of her drug cases—a ruling her legal team on Thursday said it would challenge.
In a 12-page decision dated April 30, authored by Associate Justice Eleuterio Bathan, the CA’s Eighth Division granted the Office of the Solicitor General’s (OSG) petition and declared the 2023 decision of the Muntinlupa Regional Trial Court (RTC) Branch 204 null and void.
This case is the second of three drug charges from which De Lima had been cleared.
READ: Leila de Lima maintains CA decision not reversal of her acquittal
The appellate court ruled that Presiding Judge Abraham Joseph Alcantara of Muntinlupa RTC Branch 204 committed grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction when he failed to clearly and distinctly state the facts and legal basis for acquitting De Lima and her former aide, Ronnie Dayan, of conspiracy to commit drug trading.
“We remand the case to the Regional Trial Court, Branch 204, Muntinlupa City, for it to decide the case in accordance with the rules stated in this Decision,” the CA said.
Dino de Leon, De Lima’s lawyer, said that based on their reading, the CA merely ordered the lower court to issue a new decision following the guidelines laid out in the ruling.
Not yet final
“This decision of the CA is not yet final. We believe that the Court of Appeals committed a reversible error. Hence, we will file a motion for reconsideration,” De Leon told the Inquirer in a Viber message on Thursday.
For now, De Lima, who is poised to assume a seat in the House of Representatives as the first nominee of the Liberal party list, remains free, he said. “She will continue to be free and proceed with her preparations for public office. Truth is on her side, so she is unfazed by this latest development.”
The CA ruling stemmed from the OSG’s petition to nullify the May 12, 2023, decision and the July 6, 2023, order in Criminal Case No. 17-165.
Alcantara’s decision cited “reasonable doubt” as the basis for the acquittal, particularly after former Bureau of Corrections chief Rafael Ragos recanted his testimony that he delivered drug money to De Lima through Dayan.
‘Coerced’ by Aguirre
In an affidavit presented to the media at the time, Ragos said former Justice Secretary Vitaliano Aguirre II “coerced” him to “admit something that did not happen.” He affirmed his recantation in court in November 2022.
The OSG contested the RTC’s decision, accusing Alcantara of grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction when he issued the ruling “without clear and distinct reference to the evidence and law upon which it is based.”
Government lawyers said Alcantara unjustly disregarded the testimonies of other prosecution witnesses, which clearly established the guilt of De Lima and Dayan for illegal drug trading, and that the judge failed to test the credibility of witness Ragos’ recantation.
De Lima, in her response to the OSG’s petition, urged the appellate court to dismiss the petition outright, saying it was a prohibited appeal from a judgment of acquittal.
Double jeopardy
She argued that granting the petition would violate her constitutional protection against double jeopardy.
She also asserted that the guarantee against double jeopardy not only bars multiple prosecutions but also prohibits an appeal from a judgment of acquittal.
She repeated her position in a statement on Thursday.
De Lima said the CA’s decision “does not mean that my acquittal is no longer valid.”
“I also wish to clarify that the CA did not say that my acquittal was reversed; rather, it only asked for the RTC decision to be clarified or revised —something we believe is unnecessary because the RTC’s ruling is already clear,” she said.
In siding with the OSG, the three-member CA division said that Alcantara failed to discuss in his decision the specific proven facts as well as the laws upon which his pronouncement of acquittal was based.
It pointed out that the ruling failed to indicate which parts of Ragos’ testimony had been retracted, how those retractions affected the prosecution’s case, and which elements of the crime had not been proven.
“The absence of a detailed enumeration or substantive discussion of the statements allegedly withdrawn by witness Ragos renders it exceedingly difficult, if not impossible, to discern the rationale behind the public respondent’s findings and ultimate conclusion,” the CA said.
On the recantations
Without specific references to the recanted testimony, the CA said, “We were left to speculate as to which facts were disregarded and the extent to which such retractions influenced the outcome of the case.”
The court said that under the Constitution, no court shall render a decision without clearly and distinctly stating the facts and the law on which it is based.
It also cited the Revised Rules of Criminal Procedure, which require judges to personally prepare and sign decisions that meet these same standards.
READ:; De Lima, Diokno to join House team prosecuting VP Duterte
“Thus, in order for a judgment or decision in a criminal case to have a legal and binding effect, it must conform to the standards of clarity, transparency, and reasonableness as mandated both by the Constitution and the Rules of Court. However, in this case, we find that both the assailed Decision and Order failed to meet these required standards,” the CA said.
Proving conspiracy
The CA further noted that Alcantara’s decision to acquit De Lima and Dayan “appears to rest predominantly on the purported failure to prove the existence of conspiracy.”
“It must be emphasized, however, that conspiracy, within the context of the present case, is not an independent offense but merely a mode of perpetrating the crime charged,” it said.
As to De Lima’s argument on double jeopardy, the CA ruled that her acquittal was not valid since it was based on a “void judgment.”
The court explained that for double jeopardy to apply, several elements must be present: the accused must be formally charged; the court must have jurisdiction; the accused must have been arraigned and pleaded; and the case must have ended in either acquittal, conviction, or dismissal without the accused’s consent.
“The presence of grave abuse of discretion effectively nullifies the public respondent’s jurisdiction, thereby negating the second requisite of double jeopardy. To this, therefore, an acquittal rendered through a judgment marred by grave abuse of discretion cannot be considered an acquittal entitled to the protection against double jeopardy,” the CA said.
No political ‘obstacle’
In her statement on Thursday. De Lima said that “all the answers” to the CA’s questions could be seen in the records of the case.
“Maybe we would just have to direct them again to our motion for reconsideration, which contains the specific portions of records where they could see the answers to their questions,” she said.
READ: De Lima accepts House invitation to join impeachment prosec team
The former senator said her acquittal was “final and unappealable because of the principle of double jeopardy, while the decision of the CA is still appealable. For now, the acquittal of the RTC still has more weight.”
She added that the CA’s decision would not be an “obstacle” to her return to public service.
“I will continue with my preparations in championing justice and reform in Congress,” she said.
She said the three charges were trumped up and instigated by then-President Rodrigo Duterte, angered by her investigation of the alleged extrajudicial killings in his war on drugs since he was mayor of Davao City. —With a report from Inquirer Research
(2025/05/16-05:30)
INQUIRER
- 07/03 05:34 ‘Genuine’ Filipinos won’t cower before China, says Malacañang
- 07/03 05:04 Baguio execs renew bid to collect P200M in John Hay revenue
- 07/03 02:20 Aboitiz Power keen on scaling up solar capacity
- 07/02 17:11 7 Chinese nationals arrested in Pampanga for telecom fraud
- 07/02 13:40 Palace: Harry Roque’s remark on his PH departure is ‘barber’s gossip’
- 07/02 13:06 Del Monte Foods seeks US bankruptcy protection, asset sale
- 07/02 11:26 Peza clears P72B investments in 1st semester
- 07/02 08:02 Philippines remains stuck in lower middle-income group
- 07/02 05:25 Smuggled onions, mackerel worth P34M seized at Manila port
- 07/02 04:30 SC issues writ of kalikasan vs Samal-Davao bridge project
- 07/02 02:11 Philippine factory activity recovered in June
- 07/02 02:08 More int’l flights coming to Manila, says Naia operator
- 07/02 02:02 P1-B budget sought to start corn procurement program
- 07/01 14:32 Marcos weighing public sentiment on PH return to ICC – Palace
- 07/01 13:10 China bars ex-senator Tolentino from entering its territories over WPS stance
- 07/01 12:22 Bill to set public school teachers' minimum wage at P50,000 refiled
- 07/01 11:53 Smuggled agri products worth P34M seized
- 07/01 11:26 PSE approves Keppel Philippines delisting on July 8
- 07/01 09:50 Teodoro: Time for PAF to have airborne early warning, control system
- 07/01 05:45 Study: WPS, Benham Rise world’s soft coral hot spots
- 07/01 04:40 Fishers’ group rejects US ammo factory in Subic Bay
- 07/01 02:14 Fuel discounts for PUVs launched amid rollback
- 07/01 02:13 BSP still sees below-target June inflation despite oil price spike
- 06/30 17:04 Teodoro on US-proposed Subic ammo plant: It's ‘definitely encouraged’
- 06/30 13:08 Philippines, Lithuania sign defense pact amid West PH Sea challenges
- 06/30 09:27 Senate open to proposals to improve public access to budget process
- 06/30 05:55 Manila court: Alice Guo ‘a Chinese national’
- 06/30 05:45 Village halls in Albay’s Ligao City go solar
- 06/30 05:35 MMDA completes switch to adaptive traffic lights
- 06/30 02:08 Airlines in Asia-Pacific see turbulence ahead
- 06/30 02:07 Higher deficit ceiling forces tweaks to Philippines' borrowing plan
- 06/30 02:06 MVP awaits big buyers, steady market for Maynilad IPO
- 06/27 11:26 DILG: Paralegal aid frees nearly 68,000 detainees to ease jail crowding
- 06/27 11:08 Subic-Clark-Manila- Batangas cargo railway gets technical aid from USTDA
- 06/27 10:44 Filipinos in Hawaii urged to get US citizenship amid ICE crackdown
- 06/27 09:46 2 Chinese arrested for shooting at Filipino in Makati City
- 06/27 05:48 Escudero, Romualdez likely to keep top posts
- 06/27 05:30 Cayetano warns vs rushed dismissal of impeachment raps
- 06/27 02:34 Marcos gov't cuts 2025 growth outlook on the Philippines
- 06/27 02:30 Gov’t back to budget deficit in May, but smaller
- 06/27 02:18 AboitizPower launches P30-B retail bond offer
- 06/27 02:10 AI-enabled commerce coming soon to digital store near you
- 06/26 15:05 DTI: Prices of basic goods remain stable amid global risks
- 06/26 14:55 Palace hits back after Sara Duterte defends ‘personal’ Australia visit
- 06/26 12:28 Fisherman finds P166.6-M drugs at sea, turns them over to PDEA
- 06/26 10:48 ALI, Globe land on TIME’s list of sustainable companies
- 06/26 05:36 DOJ eyes Japan tech in search for missing cockfighters
- 06/26 05:32 House prosecutors submit Sara Duterte impeach complaint certification
- 06/26 05:30 DOJ heeds ICC ‘request’ to assist witnesses
- 06/26 04:30 From mangroves to meals
- 06/26 02:28 BSP: Number of fake banknotes surged by 18.4% in 2024
- 06/26 00:19 DFA launches book promoting PH Studies programs abroad
- 06/25 17:00 Peso strengthens to 56:$1 as Middle East optimism weakens dollar
- 06/25 16:04 West PH Sea: Recent US-PH-Japan sea drills viewed as ‘counter-China’ effort
- 06/25 13:10 Pope Leo XIV appoints Br. Armin Luistro to Vatican dicastery
- 06/25 13:00 PNP-ACG: Most online scammers now are Filipinos who ‘learned’ from Pogos
- 06/25 11:47 Romualdez: House commits to fund thousands of new teaching posts
- 06/25 10:42 Marcos: No need for fuel subsidy talks as prices have not risen
- 06/25 05:55 Duterte rant, partner Avanceña’s rage cited to block his release
- 06/25 05:45 AFP battle staff readies plans amid Middle East tensions
- 06/25 02:09 Faster 5.6% Philippine GDP growth seen in Q2
- 06/25 02:02 BSP wants banks to adopt model risk management
- 06/24 14:12 Chinese submersible drones’ sinister roles in expansionism
- 06/24 13:33 AFP ready to aid gov't in repatriating Filipinos in Iran, Israel
- 06/24 09:19 31 Filipino repatriates from Middle East now safe – DMW
- 06/24 08:29 Padilla seeks Duterte repatriation, but Senate rejects his resolution
- 06/24 02:10 Philippine peso, stocks feel pressure of world on edge
- 06/24 02:08 Middle East war may cut short BSP easing, say analysts
- 06/24 02:03 Offshore wind projects get boost as Philippines launches road map
- 06/24 02:01 Philippines linking rural farms to markets via steel bridges
- 06/23 13:35 More than 100 Filipinos in Israel lost their homes – PH embassy
- 06/23 11:47 Panfilo Lacson says US bombing of Iran nuke sites could start world war
- 06/23 05:50 Over 200 Filipinos in Israel, Iran seeking repatriation
- 06/23 05:20 Carpio: Sara Duterte risks waiving rights without response to court
- 06/23 02:10 Philippine banks cut property exposure to lowest in 6 years
- 06/23 02:08 Property firms endure condo glut
- 06/23 02:07 Likely better harvest lessens rice imports
- 06/22 05:32 Next week’s fuel price hike seen exceeding P5 per liter
- 06/21 18:07 Marcos: ‘We did not yield’ on West Philippine Sea issue
- 06/20 14:42 Sara Duterte may be violating obligation with her trips abroad – Palace
- 06/20 12:51 Marcos meets Japanese tourism partners on 2nd day of Japan trip
- 06/20 11:29 Sara Duterte on personal trip to Australia to join rally for her father
- 06/20 08:58 DOTr studying train line upgrades – Dizon
- 06/20 05:32 UN rapporteur urges PH to return as ICC member
- 06/20 04:00 Philippine conglomerates increase investments in health care
- 06/20 02:20 AGI eyes new luxury hotel, malls through P59-B buildout
- 06/20 02:16 Robinsons Land pumps up REIT arm with 9 more malls
- 06/20 02:10 Preparing Philippine businesses for sustainability compliance
- 06/19 17:59 Torre to police commanders: ‘Don’t hide in your offices’
- 06/19 14:22 New COVID-19 'Nimbus' variant not yet detected in PH, says DOH chief
- 06/19 12:07 Killing of P200 pay hike bill also kills bid for living wage
- 06/19 11:40 7 Filipinos hurt in Iran missile strikes on Israel – PH embassy
- 06/19 11:08 Meralco unit PacificLight switches on 100-MW plant in Singapore
- 06/19 09:56 PH peso sinks back to 57:$1 as US Fed hold boosts dollar
- 06/19 05:12 Barbers pushes for AI-regulating gov’t agency
- 06/19 02:22 DTI launches supply chain, logistics center to support MSMEs
- 06/19 02:18 Firms in Spain earn nod to send meat to the Philippines
- 06/18 16:51 PSEi retreats as Israel-Iran conflict rises
- 06/18 12:25 Motorists will get fuel subsidies due to Mideast tension – Marcos
- 06/18 09:15 Zero dengue deaths by 2030 possible – scientific working group
- 06/18 08:54 Experts urge PH gov't to expedite approval of new dengue vaccine
- 06/18 02:16 Gov’t orders DOE to ensure sufficient oil supply
- 06/18 02:13 Philippines to adopt OECD cryptocurrency tax framework
- 06/18 02:10 New incentives program for electric vehicles seen ‘more inclusive’
- 06/18 02:09 San Miguel leads Philippine firms in ‘Southeast Asia 500’ list
- 06/18 02:04 Philippine exit from list of ‘risky’ markets seen raising investor interest
- 06/17 13:12 MMDA: Driver caught 309 times for same traffic violation in 10 months
- 06/17 12:00 DOTr chief commits privatization of 10 airports by 2028
- 06/17 10:49 House refusal to accept Duterte lawyers’ entry may delay trial – Senate
- 06/17 07:01 Philippines climbs to 51st in global competitiveness report
- 06/17 05:45 Filipina worker wounded in airstrikes vs Israel ‘critical’
- 06/17 02:14 Israel-Iran conflict seen unlikely to derail BSP rate cut
- 06/16 19:07 Senate, House tell agencies: Monitor, help Filipinos caught in war
- 06/16 13:58 Marcos on Filipinos in Israel: Make sure ‘no one is left behind’
- 06/16 11:27 Marcos orders agencies: Prioritize power, internet access in schools
- 06/16 05:40 4 Filipinos in Israel injured amid air strikes
- 06/16 05:36 PH, Japan hold joint drills after RAA
- 06/16 05:32 Problems of past class opening persist in current school year
- 06/16 02:32 Stage set for fresh BSP rate cut to 5.25%
- 06/16 02:26 Final price caps set for clean energy auction
- 06/16 02:20 NEA tasked to help co-ops secure green energy requirements
- 06/15 14:49 DA estimates over 200,000 metric tons of tuna catch in 2024
- 06/13 18:24 AboitizPower P100-B bond program gets SEC approval
- 06/13 17:01 DA lifts ban on beef, poultry products from Germany, Belgium
- 06/13 17:01 DA lifts ban on beef, poultry products from Germany, Belgium
- 06/13 14:55 Edsa 2’s lessons for Sara Duterte trial from Joseph Estrada’s fall
- 06/13 11:55 Sotto: Sen. Miriam taught me that senator-judges can’t make motions
- 06/13 02:30 BSP orders banks to go beyond OTPs
- 06/13 02:24 Filinvest hosts Qatar Airways’ first Philippine office
- 06/13 00:50 Rodrigo Duterte appeals for an interim release from ICC detention
- 06/12 21:56 Marcos offers condolences to India over deadly plane crash
- 06/12 15:34 Chief justice on Independence day: Combat corruption, apathy
- 06/12 14:49 Christian Monsod: Senate decision to remand ‘railroading a wrong power’
- 06/12 13:36 Taiwan’s TPEx tapped to help Philippine SMEs, bond market grow
- 06/12 13:08 Strong, credible voices reverberate vs ‘delay’ in Sara Duterte trial
- 06/12 10:33 Pulong Duterte celebrates independence but dad's detention leaves pain
- 06/12 07:30 Agriculture group urges Marcos to block P200 daily wage hike
- 06/12 06:00 Marcos: Value the nation’s heritage by protecting rights, freedoms
- 06/12 05:44 House, Senate in stalemate over proposed pay hike
- 06/12 05:42 PH removed from EU’s ‘high risk’ dirty money list
- 06/12 02:32 Legislated wage hikes to harm economy, hurt poor Filipinos - economic team
- 06/11 16:29 Solon raises alarm over ASF vaccines for alleged mutation risks
- 06/11 16:24 House to seek clarity on Senate’s remand before receiving case
- 06/11 15:37 No court jurisdiction lost in Sara Duterte impeachment case - Escudero
- 06/11 15:05 Protesters rally in numbers at Senate over Duterte trial delay
- 06/11 13:29 Big business group 'deeply concerned' over stalled Sara Duterte impeachment trial
- 06/11 13:02 Economic team warns of ‘dangerous repercussions’ of P200 wage hike
- 06/11 11:07 Philippines exits EU ‘high-risk’ dirty money list
- 06/11 09:05 Philippine agricultural trade deficit narrows in April
- 06/11 02:28 BSP: FDIs extended slump in March
- 06/10 13:01 41 Chinese vessels seen in various parts of West Philippine Sea in May
- 06/09 14:57 PCG to assess damage caused by grounded Chinese ship off Pag-asa island
- 06/09 12:19 Impeachment process has ‘constitutional infirmities’ – Sara Duterte team
- 06/09 11:36 Senate minority to initiate Sara Duterte impeachment trial this Monday
- 06/09 09:51 F-16 maker sees US making formal offer to PH for fighter jets
- 06/09 05:30 FDA adds 10 more drugs to VAT-free medications
- 06/09 02:09 Philippine market tagged best in SE Asia on slowing inflation
- 06/09 02:07 US agri exports seen growing as Philippines' middle class expands
- 06/09 00:11 South Korea seen to seek deeper security cooperation with PH
- 06/08 02:12 AI is unlocking human potential in new ways
- 06/06 15:23 PH-Japan reciprocal access agreement gets House of Councillors' OK
- 06/06 14:11 ICC prosecutors submit 7th batch of evidence vs Rodrigo Duterte
- 06/06 13:31 Prosecution to present impeachment articles no matter what – Zamora
- 06/06 09:43 Joblessness in the Philippines worsens in April
- 06/06 02:28 Japan debt watcher keeps Philippines' ‘A’ rating
- 06/05 09:16 Inflation cools to 1.3% in May, slowest pace in nearly 6 years
- 06/05 04:36 Reusing plastic ‘a win for everyone’
- 06/05 04:34 Wind power drives Camarines Sur’s energy shift
- 06/05 04:32 In Palawan, a resilient system of seaweed farming
- 06/05 02:28 Philippines may miss growth goal this 2025 – OECD
- 06/04 14:14 Torre pushes for continuing education for police officers
- 06/04 13:25 DA extends issuance of fish import permit till June
- 06/04 12:19 PNP sets 5-minute police response time in a pilot test for Metro Manila
- 06/04 05:55 Senate pressed to fulfill mandate, hold Sara Duterte trial
- 06/04 05:00 DOH seeks emergency declaration on HIV surge
- 06/04 04:55 Marcos lauds upgrades at Naia Terminal 3
- 06/04 02:08 Gov’t debt hit fresh high of P16.75T in April
- 06/04 02:05 BSP enables banks to freeze funds
- 06/04 00:03 DMW to help OFW who had in-flight miscarriage aboard S. Korean plane
- 06/03 16:30 Castro on delayed impeachment trial: Is Senate taking revenge on House?